[Framework for evaluating the performance of local healthcare: international experiences and prospects for Italy.] / Framework per la valutazione della performance dell'assistenza sanitaria territoriale: esperienze internazionali e prospettive per l'Italia.

The Italian National healthcare service currently lacks a synthetic framework for measuring the primary care legislative reform established by the National recovery and resilience plan and the legislative reform, Decree number 77/2022. This paper explores the existing international and national literature on primary care' monitoring and evaluation systems with the purpose of drawing guidelines to build up a global and systematic framework. The 2022 World health organization framework is the most advanced reference point as a result of more than twenty years of theoretical and field research. Indeed, it can be regarded as the basic model to be adapted to the specificities of the current Italian legislation and organization.

[Relationship between hospital volumes and health outcomes: epidemiological evidence supporting the revision process of the Ministry of Health Decree no. 70 of 2 April 2015.] / Relazione tra volumi di attività ed esiti dell'assistenza ospedaliera: evidenze epidemiologiche a supporto del processo di revisione del Decreto del Ministero della Salute n. 70 del 2 aprile 2015.

Since its enactment on 2 April 2015, the Decree of the Ministry of Health no.70 has provided a key framework for the reorganization of services to enhance the quality and safety of care. This decree presents the volume thresholds for a series of nosological areas and diagnostic-therapeutic procedures, aiming to improve healthcare outcomes. These thresholds are expected to be periodically updated based on the most recent scientific developments. AIM: In this perspective, this work intends to establish whether statistical correlations exist between volumes of activity and outcomes of hospital care. The scope is limited to several clinical conditions and therapeutic procedures for which specific indicators are provided by the National Healthcare Outcomes Programme (Programma Nazionale Esiti - PNE). METHODS: For each condition or procedure, the analysis shows the volume-outcome relationship by hospital centre by means of the Levenberg-Marquardt algorithm (software: XLSTAT). The existence of breakpoints is assessed through the use of segmented models (software: "segmented" R-Package). RESULTS: The results show a statistical correlation for the following: acute myocardial infarction (breakpoint: 91 hospitalizations per year; 95% CI: 81-101; p<0.0001); repair of an unruptured abdominal aortic aneurysm (breakpoint: 69 procedures per year; 95% CI: 52-86; p=0.146); lung cancer (breakpoint: 96 procedures per year; 95% CI: 60-132; p<0.01); knee arthroplasty (breakpoint: 91 procedures per year; 95% CI: 51-131; p=0.484). Conversely, the statistical analysis did not allow to accurately highlight a breakpoint for the isolated aorto-coronary bypass, percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty and hip arthroplasty. CONCLUSIONS: These results represent a useful knowledge contribution to support the revision process of the above-mentioned Decree. As regards the procedures that may not be currently assessed through this statistical analysis method, literature data is referred to that confirm that the current regulatory thresholds are in the safe range.

Infectious and dermatological diseases among arriving migrants on the Italian coasts.

Background: Since 2008 Italy has been the destination of the 'central Mediterranean route', used by migrants to reach Europe. The aim of this study is to describe demographic characteristics and health problems of migrants at the time of arrival on the Italian coasts, focussing on dermatological and infectious diseases. Methods: Cross-sectional study of data routinely collected (n = 6, 188) by the National Institute for Health Migration and Poverty (INMP) in the centres for migrants of Lampedusa and Trapani-Milo (2015-16). Logistic models were performed to identify factors associated with scabies, varicella and the occurrence of two or more not related diagnosis. Results: The average age was 21.6 years; 83.5% of the patients were males. The most frequent countries of origin were Eritrea, Nigeria, and Somalia. The most frequent diagnosis was scabies (58% of patients), skin infections, pediculosis and dermatitis; respiratory infections and varicella were the most represented infectious diseases. The diagnosis of scabies was more probable among Somalis (OR: 11.60) and Eritreans (OR: 10.05); the diagnosis of varicella was more probable among Ghanaians (OR: 13.58) and Nigerians (OR: 9.79). Somalis (OR: 4.10) and Eritreans (OR: 3.32) were the patients more likely to receive two or more diagnosis. Conclusions: The majority of the diseases affecting migrants is in most cases, related to the migration experience and is likely not to represent a major threat for public health. Up-to-date information regarding the burden of diseases is needed in order to identify the health needs of incoming migrants and to arrange the appropriate response in terms of health services provision.

[Undocumented immigrants: what do we know about their health?] / Capitolo 8: Gli immigrati irregolari: cosa sappiamo della loro salute?

In Italy, immigrants represent a "fuzzy" set, to which it is difficult to apply dichotomous categories as a classification (i.e., regular/irregular, economic/forced, etcetera). These categories lose its meaning when used to study health phenomena. Rather, the epidemiological profile of such a heterogeneous population depends on the varying influence of health determinants in the life-course of migration. This article builds on those assumptions, and analyses the health of irregularly- staying immigrants by adopting a global approach to the migration phenomenon. The article aims at identifying cross-sectional elements of continuity and epidemiological dynamics in the different categories. Different factors, strictly interacting with each other, strongly influence the resulting picture. Specific push-factors primarily influence the starting phases ("healthy migrant effect") and the final stages of the migration process ("salmon effect"). These factors determine good health in these groups, but are also interwined with other dynamics, connected both with the social integration process ("exhausted migrant effect") and the relation with health services, which depends on the regional and local contexts of reference. Such dynamics have been thoroughly examined for "economic migrants" arriving on the Italian coasts. However, nowadays there is important evidence that the "healthy migrant effect" can be also applied to incoming international protection seekers, as demonstrated, for example, by the low prevalence of imported infectious diseases (including tuberculosis). Mental health deserves special attention and a particular final focus, for it is a topic still not adequately addressed, in spite of the high incidence of psychic problems, caused by violence endured either before or during the journey. In the framework of migration phenomena, health issues of irregularly staying immigrants stands hence as most vulnerable, due to the overlapping effects of departure and travel conditions, and of marginalization experienced by a wide group of them in the host Country. It is, therefore, essential to pursue a balanced management of this phenomenon - rich both in implications and in opportunities - by developing highly inclusive and evidence-based public policies.

The Italian institutional accreditation model for Haemophilia Centres.

BACKGROUND: In Italy, basic health needs of patients with inherited bleeding disorders are met by a network of 50 haemophilia centres belonging to the Italian Association of Haemophilia Centres. Further emerging needs, due to the increased life expectancy of this patient group, require a multi-professional clinical management of the disease and provide a challenge to the organisation of centres.In order to achieve harmonised quality standards of haemophilia care across Italian Regions, an institutional accreditation model for haemophilia centres has been developed. MATERIAL AND METHODS: To develop an accreditation scheme for haemophilia centres, a panel of experts representing medical and patient bodies, the Ministry of Health and Regional Health Authorities has been appointed by the National Blood Centre. Following a public consultation, a technical proposal in the form of recommendations for Regional Health Authorities has been formally submitted to the Ministry of Health and has formed the basis for a proposal of Agreement between the Government and the Regions. RESULTS: The institutional accreditation model for Haemophilia Centres was approved as an Agreement between the Government and the Regions in March 2013. It identified 23 organisational requirements for haemophilia centres covering different areas and activities. DISCUSSION: The Italian institutional accreditation model aims to achieve harmonised quality standards across Regions and to implement continuous improvement efforts, certified by regional inspection systems. The identified requirements are considered as necessary and appropriate in order to provide haemophilia services as "basic healthcare levels" under the umbrella of the National Health Service. This model provides Regions with a flexible institutional accreditation scheme that can be potentially extended to other rare diseases.

Definition of an organisational model for the prevention and reduction of health and social impacts of inherited bleeding disorders.

INTRODUCTION: Due to the increase in life expectancy, patients with haemophilia and other inherited bleeding disorders are experiencing age-related comorbidities that present new challenges. In order to meet current and emerging needs, a model for healthcare pathways was developed through a project funded by the Italian Ministry of Health. The project aimed to prevent or reduce the social-health burden of the disease and its complications. MATERIAL AND METHODS: The National Blood Centre appointed a panel of experts comprising clinicians, patients, National and Regional Health Authority representatives. Following an analysis of the scientific and regulatory references, the panel drafted a technical proposal containing recommendations for Regional Health Authorities, which has been formally submitted to the Ministry of Health. Finally, a set of indicators to monitor haemophilia care provision has been defined. RESULTS: In the technical document, the panel of experts proposed the adoption of health policy recommendations summarised in areas, such as: multidisciplinary integrated approach for optimal healthcare provision; networking and protocols for emergency care; home therapy; registries/databases; replacement therapy supply and distribution; recruitment and training of experts in bleeding disorders. The recommendations became the content of proposal of agreement between the Government and the Regions. Monitoring and evaluation of haemophilia care through the set of established indicators was partially performed due to limited available data. CONCLUSIONS: The project provided recommendations for the clinical and organisational management of patient with haemophilia. A particular concern was given to those areas that play a critical role in the comorbidities and complications prevention. Recommendations are expected to harmonise healthcare care delivery across regional networks and building the foundation for the national haemophilia network.

The role of socio-economic factors on prevalence and health outcomes of persons with diabetes in Rome, Italy.

BACKGROUND: We investigated the role of socio-economic status on diabetes prevalence, on mortality and hospitalization in a large population-based cohort enrolled in Rome, Italy. METHODS: Diabetic residents aged ≥ 35 years in 2007 were identified using multiple data sources. The effect of the deprivation of the area of residence on diabetes prevalence and on mortality and hospitalization (years 2008-10) was investigated by multilevel regression models, both among diabetic and non-diabetic populations. RESULTS: Prevalence of diabetes (8.3%) was directly related to the deprivation of the area of residence, especially for women. Diabetes increased the risk of mortality and hospitalization, mainly for cardiovascular complications, compared with non-diabetic subjects, with increasing relative risks in more deprived areas. The social gradients observed among diabetic patients are modest compared with non-diabetic subjects, both for some acute complications (myocardial infarction, stroke) and chronic complications (ischaemic heart disease, nephropathy, retinopathy and amputation). CONCLUSIONS: Prevalence of diabetes is directly related to deprivation, especially for women. Diabetes increases the risk of mortality and hospitalization for cardiovascular complications. However, similar to another study conducted in Northern Italy, we found that social differences in health outcomes do not differ between people with and without diabetes, suggesting that the care for diabetic patients living in Rome is provided without social disparities, and in some cases, it protects against the adverse effects of social inequalities. The Italian care system for diabetes deserves to be further investigated, as it could represent a model for the care of other chronic conditions and for contrasting social inequities in health.

[The role of the quality of hospital discharge records on the comparative evaluation of outcomes: the example of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD)]. / Ruolo della qualità delle schede di dimissione ospedaliera nella valutazione comparativa degli esiti: l'esempio della BPCO riacutizzata.

OBJECTIVE: To analyse the results of the regional comparative evaluation of the outcome "thirty days mortality after admission for reacutized Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD)" before and after a reabstract study. DESIGN: Reabstract study of clinical records included in the regional comparative evaluation. SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: 232 clinical records retrieved from Grassi Hospital archives (years 2006-2007) and reviewed by two physicians and one nurse specifically trained. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Models performed before and after reabstract study for comparative evaluation of the outcome were compared. Blind coding of diagnosis and interventions/procedures was completed according to a standard grid consistent with regional guidelines for Hospital Discharge Record coding. Other information was registered, if present on discharge record: smoking habit, number of reacutizations occurred within previous year, use of oxigen and/or other therapies, pneumological visit at discharge. RESULTS: The majority (94%) of reviewed cases were confirmed as being cases of COPD. A total of 168 cases (72%) have been identified as reacutized COPD coherent with enrolment criteria of regional program, 49 (21%) have been identified as COPD and only 15 cases (6%) resulted not affected by COPD. Results of the regional comparative model were substantially unchanged for Grassi hospital (RR =23 vs RR =24). Accurateness of clinical documentation resulted inadequate especially regarding information at discharge (50% missing information on smoking habit, 83% on previous year reacutizations, 22% on follow-up organization after discharge). CONCLUSION: This study contributes to the debate on the role of administrative data on the comparative evaluation of health outcomes. Other relevant issues are to promote the collaboration among different health professionals working in the same hospital, and to increase the awareness of the importance of the quality of health and administrative data.

[Evaluation of hospital bed supply for surgical procedures having long waiting lists in the Lazio region, through analysis of discharge abstract data]. / Analisi dell'offerta di interventi chirurgici critici in quanto a tempi dattesa nella Regione Lazio, attraverso i dati delle schede di dimissione ospedaliera.

Certain surgical procedures have been identified in Italy as having critically long waiting times. We reviewed current hospital discharge abstract data to describe the supply for two of these surgical procedures in the Lazio region: hip replacement surgery and cataract extraction. Our results show that the regional hospital bed supply for hip replacement surgery is insufficient while for cataract extraction it is progressively increasing. The supply for hospital surgical procedures can be monitored through easily available data and can be used to support decision making in health care management.